Scholarly Communications: "Predatory" Publishers & Conferences
Useful Resources and Guides
The following links contain some useful checklists and examples of questionable publication venues:
- How to avoid predatory publishersUseful advice from the American Psychological Association (APA)
- How to avoid predatory journals—a five point planThis BMJ Blog post by Jocalyn Clark highlights five criteria to check before you submit a publication
- Predatory and Questionable Publishing Practices: How to Recognise and Avoid ThemDetailed insights and practical advice for authors on how to avoid questionable and predatory journals. Written by open access specialists at universities across the Netherlands.
- Predatory Journals, Publishers and ConferencesAvoiding Predatory Journals and Questionable Conferences: A Resource Guide. By Sarah Elaine Eaton, University of Calgary, 2018
- Investigating journals: The dark side of publishingNews feature from Nature
- Example e-mail from a predatory journalAn example of a typical email received from a potential predatory publisher from Christian Bokhove's blog.
- Study of Predatory Open Access Nursing JournalsOermann, Marilyn H., et al. "Study of Predatory Open Access Nursing Journals." Journal of Nursing Scholarship (2016).
- Flaky Academic Journals BlogBlog highlighting the questionable practices of potentially exploitative publishers and journals
Choosing a Conference
If you are uncertain of the quality or credibility of a conference, check if the conference is hosted by a well-known research institute, university or government organisation. Predatory conferences are likely to be pitched as a single one-off occurrence, rather than an annual event - in the case of the latter you can check the previous programmes and lists of speakers to help assess the quality or significance of the conference. Determine if there is a peer review process for submissions, and if possible, what the acceptance rate is.
Often there will also be an opportunity to get your research published in the journal associated with the conference. Check whether the publication is indexed in any of the major databases in your field and examine the quality of research published in previous issues.
In some disciplines rankings of conferences are available, such as CORE (Computer Science).
- Think Check AttendThink. Check. Attend. is an international initiative that aims to guide and assist researchers and scholars when choosing trusted conferences to attend and present their research at.
- CORE Conference PortalConference rankings produced by The Computing Research and Education Association of Australasia
- OMICS Group Conferences - Sham or Scam?A blog post from Richard Edwards (Cabbages of Doom blog) on his experience when attending a non-reputable conference.
Avoiding "Predatory" Publishers & Conferences
In recent years, the number of exploitative or deceptive publishers and conferences has grown. These publishers typically send unsolicited invitations to authors offering to publish their research for a substantial fee, however do not offer any of the traditional services provided by reputable publishers, such as editing, peer-review, archiving and marketing.
It is strongly recommended that authors verify the credentials of any publisher to whom they are considering submitting their work. Consider the following before submitting your manuscript:
- How long has the journal been in existence? How extensive is the available archive of back issues?
- Examine the quality of research published within the journal in previous issues
- Does the publisher provide full and transparent details of the peer review and editorial process?
- Is the journal indexed in major academic databases e.g. JSTOR, Scopus, Web of Science etc. or the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ)? Some may claim to be, but in reality are not, so it is important to verify this.
- Ask your colleagues if they have published in or are familiar with the publication.
Think, Check, Submit also has a useful checklist you can use when assessing the quality of a publication venue.
- Think Check Submit ChecklistVerify this list for your chosen journal to check if it is trusted.
- Think Check Submit - Book PublishersA checklist to help researchers verify the credentials and trustworthiness of book publishers
- Think Check AttendThink. Check. Attend. is an international initiative that aims to guide and assist researchers and scholars when choosing trusted conferences to attend and present their research at.
- Journal Evaluation Tool (LMU Library)A rubric and scoring sheet to help evaluate the quality and credibility of a journal developed at LMU by Marie Kennedy, Shilpa Rele, and Nataly Blas.
- OASPA Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly PublishingProduced by the Committee on Publication Ethics, the Directory of Open Access Journals, the Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association, and the World Association of Medical Editors
- Platform for Responsible Editorial PoliciesThe PREP database contains information on the editorial and peer review procedures of a collection of journals.
- DOAJ: Directory of Open Access JournalsAn online directory that indexes and provides access to high quality, open access, peer-reviewed journals.
If you are in any doubt regarding the credentials of a particular journal or publishers, consult the Library for further advice.
Video created by Claire Sewell, University of Cambridge Office of Scholarly Communications. Used under CC-BY licence.
Example of a typical email from a potentially deceptive publisher
Below is an example of an email received from a questionable publisher (specific details regarding the journal have been anonymised). The journal claims to have a Journal Impact factor of 1.315 but is not actually listed in the Journal Citation Reports database of impact factors. Such publishers may claim a journal is indexed in a particular database when it is not, so researchers are advised to check the database in question to verify these claims.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License